Tuesday, April 01, 2014

How I Met Your Mother

I would like to go on record as saying that I don't know how I feel about the finale of How I Met Your Mother. 

Pros:
  • Barney and Robin's unrealistic relationship was actually unrealistic. I hate that it took them all of season nine to get married and their whole marriage was over in 20 minutes of the last episode, but I feel like this was pretty honest.
  • We now know the mother's name and it is sweet that her initials are the same as Ted's.
  • I totally, totally, totally loved the moment Ted and Tracy have about the umbrella!
  • I think all the mysteries are solved...except maybe the thing about the pineapple? 
  • Ted and Tracy didn't actually get married right away. In fact, it seems like they had kids/waited several years to actually get married. I think that is interesting given how romantic he was throughout the show. 
  • Marshall and Lily. That is all. 


Cons:
  • It is just sad that Barney doesn't out grow his crap. I'm sorry, but it seems horrible that he comes out of his marriage to Robin none-the-wiser and is just back to his old tricks. I think he is smarter than that. This behavior makes it seem less likely that having a daughter would suddenly change his perspective.
  •  This show has been nine years of Ted trying to ask his kids if it is okay if he gets back together with Robin? Seriously? I can see the argument that while Tracy is THE ONE, Robin could be the love of his life. I can see the argument that THE ONE and the LOVE OF YOUR LIFE don't always have to be the same person. But seriously? Robin again?
  • I also don't buy Robin the loner, the out-cast, the one who is disengaged from everyone. She was famous and extremely successful as a teenager (Robin Sparkles!), so I bet that she would be even better at balancing everything as an adult. She was also able to "stay in the group" despite a previous break up with Barney and the break-up(s) with Ted. I think she is stronger than the way she acts in this final episode.
What did you think?

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I also have mixed feelings. The idea that Barney's daughter could change him mostly seemed ok with me - I cried like an idiot but I do love Neil Patrick Harris. I agree with your thoughts on Robin. It was strange that she would suddenly feel disengaged BUT she had a moment at the wedding where she realized TED treated her better than anyone ever had. I wonder if we were supposed to pick up on that to take us in to the finale where they end up together.

Other critics have been saying that it was annoying to have only about 20 minutes of time with the mother. I agree. I liked her a lot. But I wonder if that was also so that we wouldn't fall in love with her?

Bottom line, I wish (and had thought) that the finale would be TWO hours instead of one. It felt very rushed.

I'm also very sad it's over. That was one of the closest-to-Friends shows that I had. Now, I must depend on New Girl!