Stumping Ground
Many teachers experience the frustration of desperately trying to explain a concept and receiving, for their best efforts, the Wrinkly Face Of Confusion from their students. It is not uncommon for teachers to pull out all the stops, especially those educators who believe in their hearts that lack of understanding is a direct result and the ultimate proof that they have failed to reach the intended audience. I have personally actually lost sleep over this phenomenon. Over the course of my teaching career, I have devised a term for the times when it seems impossible to make someone else understand a concept that I think is simple; I call these moments “stumps.”
For lack of a scientific term, stumps seems most appropriate. In colloquial terms, it seems that it would be readily apparent the derivation of my meaning—I am quite literally stumped, as in completely baffled. I can make no sense of where my explanation has gone astray; in short, I have no idea why I get the Wrinkly Face Of Confusion.
It is important at this point to discuss specific examples of classroom experiences when I have encountered a stump in order to begin any kind of analytical approach for potentially solving this enigma. Therefore, a brief story is in order. During the course of my latest action-research project, I attempted to investigate the ways that critical writing-to-learn strategies applied during reading could enhance interpretive writing about the text. While in the process of this research project, I began to notice that my students seemed to develop problems with the concept of supporting a textual argument with evidence. When I modeled for the students how to cite the text in support of a literary argument, it became obvious that the students were confused as to how to use the opinions and ideas of another to supplement their own writing. After my explanation about referring to the text and documenting supporting evidence, I got the Wrinkly Face Of Confusion followed by comments like this:
“But Mrs. M! I thought that quotations had to be something that somebody in the book actually says. None of the characters actually say anything that helps me with my paper.”
No comments:
Post a Comment