Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Harry Potter--SPOILER WARNING!

Here are my initial impressions from a list I sent Dear Rachel. I will go into more detail later.

1. I'm almost disappointed that it was so easy, do you know what I mean? For instance, there is an actual LIST of the things V made into a horcrux.

2. Sam was right! We had kind of guessed that part of V's soul ended up in Harry when he tried to kill him, but I was right when I said it wasn't intentional that Harry became a Horcrux. We were also right about the snake.

3. Could she have made Harry anymore Christ-like or Asland-ish (sp?)? Geez.

4. It hurts me that Dumbledore had to become the fallen idol. I'm not sure that was necessary.

5. I think I figured out who the date-rape inference was about. Did you?

6. What was that thing (under the chair??) making all the noise while Harry was talking to Dumbledore at the end in the train station? Was it a newly born Phoenix? Was it Harry's body? Was it a baby? Was it something else that I just missed?

7. I have to confess there were parts where I actually teared up. How about you?

And I need to add--The end, the end!

2 comments:

The Poor Blogger said...

>>1. I'm almost disappointed that it was so easy, do you know what I mean? For instance, there is an actual LIST of the things V made into a horcrux.<<

To be fair, though, there was only one thing the list helped them find. What I though was too easy (and I read the last two chapters first) was the somewhat "Hollywoodesque" ending where everyone is with whom you would expect them to be with, with kids, etc.

>>2. Sam was right! We had kind of guessed that part of V's soul ended up in Harry when he tried to kill him, but I was right when I said it wasn't intentional that Harry became a Horcrux. We were also right about the snake.<<

I was right that Harry would have to die, but wrong that he would stay dead. Sadly, I was almost disappointed that he didn't stay dead, although relieved at the same time.

>>3. Could she have made Harry anymore Christ-like or Asland-ish (sp?)? Geez.<<

No fooling! There was Christianity throughout. The symbol of the Deathly Hallows is a Trinitarian one (Triangle, Circle and line divine the humanity and divinity of Christ) and Harry was the one to possess them all. The inscriptions on the gravestones were both Bible verses. Frankly, I'd be more offended by the book if I was a left-wing nutjob than a right-wing nutjob.

>>4. It hurts me that Dumbledore had to become the fallen idol. I'm not sure that was necessary.<<

I loved it, actually. I've gone from identifying with Lupin (struggling with the beast within) in Azkaban to Snape (the traitor who repents) in the chapter where Snape dies to Dumbledore, who committed acts for which he never felt he could atone. He was wise and good because he recognized his own propensity to evil and prevented himself from ever being in a position where it would tempt him again.

>>5. I think I figured out who the date-rape inference was about. Did you?<<

What? I'd never read that until you mentioned it. I looked online and all I found was the article on the Onion (a spoof news network) website (http://www.theonion.com/content/video/j_k_rowling_hints_at_harry_potter)

Where was it supposed to be?

>>6. What was that thing (under the chair??) making all the noise while Harry was talking to Dumbledore at the end in the train station? Was it a newly born Phoenix? Was it Harry's body? Was it a baby? Was it something else that I just missed?<<

It was the part of Voldemort's soul that was in Harry Potter and which Voldemort killed. It was dying at King's Cross station.

>>7. I have to confess there were parts where I actually teared up. How about you?<<

Absolutely! Especially when Dobby died. The whole scene, from Harry digging the grave to all the people putting clothes on Dobby, it was all too much!

Can't wait to read what you write. I'll send you the link to my post when I've finished it.

Peace,
Christopher

The Poor Blogger said...

To my knowledge, the etymology of the worlds is as follows:
- "Witch" comes from the Old English "wicce", the female form of "wicca"
- The root word for "wizard" is the same as "wise."
- "Warlock" comes from the Old English "waerloga" or oathbreaker.
- "Magic," "mage," and "magus" are all related and, ultimately, come from the Greek. Interestingly, speaking of Christianity, the Three Wise Men are also known as the "Magi." Magi is another related word referring to Zoroastrians priests who were also astrologers (GASP!). Thus, they read the stars and followed the Christmas Star.

What is interesting about these words is that all of them have positive connotations in their roots EXCEPT for "warlock." My guess, without having researched it myself, is that "warlock" is a word applied to practitioners of magic by those who believed it to be evil (probably Christians, although it is frowned upon in many religions).

From a feminist perspective, despite the negative root of "warlock," it is interesting to note that the male terms for a magician ("wizard" and "warlock") have a more or less positive slant to them today, while "witch" has a negative one. Speaking of feminism, where is the Office of Equality in the Ministry of Magic?