Wow! Many of you have far more profound thoughts on Harry's last book than I do (go read the comments that have been posted for example--especially my friend, poor-blogger.) I am getting ready to disappoint many of you who somehow expect me to have brilliant things to say about all books because I teach English. Oh well...
I'm almost disappointed that it was so easy... For instance, there is an actual LIST of the things V made into a horcrux. I found myself slightly irritated that I didn't have to think very much with this book because I've gotten so used to constantly having to engage my brain with the rest of them. Other things that bothered me included the almost immediate explanations of things such as Ron's use of the deluminator, the thorough explanation about the story of the three brothers (and it's multiple means in light of Harry, Ron, and Hermione's quest), and Dumbledore's chat with Harry at the end of the book.
Could she have made Harry anymore Christ-like or Asland-ish? First, I have to say that I am not sure what else she could have done, so it isn't like I am smart enough to offer any alternatives or anything. But I do want to wonder aloud whether or not this is a response to those critics who wanted to ban Harry Potter because "it promot(ed) Satanism." Well, obviously not! I would argue that these books are about truth and courage, love and friendship rather than anything Satanic. Those of you who have postulated that HP as a series is ultimately about Death also make very good (and interesting) points, although I have to say that I wouldn't have really thought about it this way until I finished reading the very last book. Nathan read the first few pages where Rowling quotes Aeschylus and William Penn, looked up at me and said, "That's it. Harry is going to die." I certainly didn't think so. But those of you who look back and say, yes, these books are indeed about death and what it means to die (or what death means in terms of how one lives) have ample reason to suggest that right here.
That Dumbledore had to become the fallen idol totally breaks my heart in addition to ruining how I feel about him. I know that what we learn about Dumbledore (this situation with his mom and sister, the ill-advised friendship with the wand-maker, the accident, the selfish motives in helping Harry) all serve to make him more human. My question is why? Why did he need to become more flawed? It's not like we are going to see Harry grow anymore as a result of this knowledge. It's not like Dumbledore needed to unburden his soul. In fact, Dumbledore is already dead. Which is another thing (Rachel, I totally agree with you here), it is totally irrelevant that Dumbledore died in book six if he gets to come back to sit with Harry in the train station and tell Harry what it all means like he has always done. It would have been more meaningful if Harry had figured it out for himself this time. How does the hero grow or learn anything if his mentor is always there explaining everything? That is just frustrating.
Did anyone else hear the comment Rowling made about how there was an implied reference to a date rape in book seven? Well, I did. I admit to being pretty shocked by this (aren't these children's books?), but morbidly curious at the same time. Anyway, I think I've figured out what she was talking about. Doesn't it seem odd to anyone that at the beginning of book seven we suddenly learn that Tonks and Lupin are married and just as suddenly we are informed that she is pregnant?
I've asked everyone I know who has read the book what that weird thing under the chair was in the train station when Harry is chatting with Dumbledore. It seems unanimous that it was the part of Voldemort's soul that had detached itself from Harry and was dying. I know that most questing heroes have to go to the Underworld to gain at least some knowledge and this little sojourn in King's Cross is the closest thing to that, in my opinion. Harry is basically somewhere between life and death, chatting with a spirit, determining answers to some of his questions which will ultimately direct him when he returns to his life. If the screaming thing under the chair is a part of Voldemort's dying soul, then that is further evidence for me that the train station at King's Cross is at least some version of the Underworld.
I know that Rowling talked about the multiple, untimely deaths that readers would face in book seven, but honestly, the only one that tore at my soul was the death of Dobby, the house-elf. Reading about Harry digging the grave for Dobby himself and everyone giving a piece of clothing to Dobby's body totally broke my heart. I have been proud of the person Harry has become before, but this choice touched me and made me cry.
And I need to add--The end, the end! Why 19 years? Why did we need to be told? Do we all need that kind of specific closure? I am not saying that I didn't enjoy it--because we all know that I love resolution, but I almost wish that it wasn't all tidied up, I'd like to have some room left for imagination.
2 comments:
Ooooh, I got a link!
I've already said all I've got to say, but I think the date rape scene is a joke put on by the "Onion." Where did Rowling herself talk about it? The only place I can even imagine where something like that was implied is what happened to Ariana, Albus' sister. Whatever the Muggle boys did to her was so bad that her dad went to prison for what he did in retaliation.
I will agree that the end, including the "19 years later" was kind of Hollywood. As well as all the centaurs and house elves and thestrals and hippogriffs coming out to fight the Death Eaters. I can already see that scene in my mind's eye. And, although I'm glad to know what happened to Harry later in life, it did make it a little ... trite. If Harry was going to live (and I was sure he had to die), then nothing more needed to be said past the repairing of his wand. That would have been a good end to the book.
Although, I did love it when Luna suggested that he escape to get some alone time and rest. That rocked. She rocks.
Peace,
Me
Thought you might be interested in this:
http://poor-blogger.blogspot.com/2007/08/did-dumbledore-manipulate-harry.html
Post a Comment