Saturday, August 13, 2005

Harry Potter--SPOILER WARNING!

Okay, I admit it. I am a Harry Potter fan. I've always wanted to be a witch and Rowling's world so perfectly imagines everything that I could want my life as a witch to be. So for those of you who have read book 6 and want to hear what I think, here goes. I must first assign credit to my friends who have discussed these books with me and shared their own opinions. I am certainly not taking credit for having all of these thoughts, insights, and opinions originally.

1) The death of Dumbledore.
As an English teacher, I pay close attention to archetypes patterns. It therefore seems to me that Dumbledore's death makes sense if Rowling is adhering to any kind of hero archetype. I am thinking specifically that Harry, as the hero, must complete his quest (to end the ordeal with Voldemort, to become a "man" [read: grow up], to become a powerful wizard...) and that in order to do this, all those who have helped or mentored him must somehow be removed. Among my friends, there is a tentative theory that Dumbledore, as a result of drinking the water in the cave, somehow is not exactly dead. I don't think that they mean he isn't LITERALLY dead, but more that the liquid may somehow have allowed him to transcend death as we typically think of it. (I personally believe that he is, in fact, dead. I must admit, though, that I lend much credibility to this line of thinking.) However, I am also suspicious that Dumbeldore is sleeping in his portrait, and that no other reference to the state of his hand is made. I also have several things to comment on regarding the actual death scene and Professor Snape, but I will address those items when I discuss my opinions about Snape.

2) Snape: Good or Evil?
I know that many people are disposed to believe that Snape is EVIL... and I mean evil to the core. I can understand why these people are so adamant about their hatred for Snape---he is certainly not likeable. I think he is down right scary. But everyone has to admit that at no point in any of the six books has Dumbledore's position/attitude about Snape wavered. He always says that his trust in Professor Snape is absolute and unfaltering. So, although this is probably unpopular and I risk being dead wrong, I'm going on record as saying that I'm with Dumbledore: I trust Snape.
I have several reasons other than Dumbledore trusts him. At the end of book 6 when the dark mark appears above Hogwarts and the battle takes place, Snape does several things that make me suspect that he isn't a traitor. For example, Snape tells Hermione and Luna to go inside his office and care for Professor Flitwick because he had "collapsed." I think that Snape was protecting the girls by distracting them with the hexed Flitwick while he went off to the tower to manage the problem with the Death Eaters. Furthermore, as Harry is chasing Snape and the Death Eaters off the grounds of Hogwarts, Harry is continually attempting to curse Snape. However, Snape does not retaliate. In fact, he tells Harry, "No Unforgivable Curses from you... (pg 602), and he deflects every curse directed at him. Additionally, when one of the Death Eaters hits Harry with a curse designed to cripple him with pain, Snape intervenes explaining that Harry is to be left for the Dark Lord. He saves Harry.
I also believe that Snape did not expect Narcissa to add the third and final part of the Unbreakable Vow, "And, should it prove necessary...if it seems Draco will fail...will you carry out the deed that the Dark Lord has ordered Draco to perform?" (pg 36). I don't think that Snape wanted to kill Dumbledore; I actually think he was angry about having to do it.
The death scene, when read with a lens that includes this perspective, is not as it first seems. I don't believe that Snape cold-bloodedly kills Dumbledore at all. Rowling writes on pg 595:

"Snape gazed for a moment at Dumbledore, and there was
revulsion and hatred etched in the harsh lines of his face.

'Severus...please...'

Snape raised his want and pointed it directly at Dumbledore.

'Avada Kedavra!'"

Note that there is no indication of what causes the "revulsion and hatred etched in the harsh lines of [Snape's] face." Could it not result from having to kill Dumbledore as the result of the Unbreakable Vow? Could it not be because of his unfortunate past association with the Dark Lord that has placed him in this unimaginable predicament? Certainly, one has to admit that this is plausible.

I must believe that Rowling's view of the human condition allows room for characters like Snape to change...to re-think their past deeds and alliances. To counter those individuals who will point out how much Snape appears to hate Harry, I would argue that considering how poorly Snape was treated by James Potter, it is not hard to believe that Snape would harbor some resentment towards Harry. I think this makes Snape very human indeed, which only strengthens my belief that Snape is not as evil as he appears--and he is worthy of the trust the Dumbledore gives him.

3) Who is RAB?
I am certain that others have already pointed out that the most likely candidate for this mystery is Sirius's brother, Regulus. I won't go into the page long explanation of what happened to Regulus, but I will say that there is strong textual evidence in the conversation Harry has with Sirius in the context of the Tapestry containing the Black family tree. This conversation begins on page 111 of the Hardback Scholastic Edition of Book 5 and continues to page 112.

4) The Horcruxes
Several of my friends and I have rattled our brains about what the remaining Horcruxes could be. We have hypothesized that the ones belonging to Gryffindor and Hufflepuff may actually be inside Hogwarts. This gives Harry a reason to return to the school in book 7, which we just can't imagine him not doing. We've also considered the possibility that the snake of Lord Voldemort's might be one, although I think that it is silly to make a horcrux out of something organic that might die. It seems that it is more likely to be a rule of Rowling's imagined world that Horcruxes must be inanimate objects, although she has not stated this anywhere. We've also been sentimental enough to toss around the idea that Harry's Invisibility Cloak might have been a Horcrux, but I'm not all too sure about that. It would certainly be ironic, but....
I'm going to throw the idea out that something in Sirius's house might be a Horcrux and that Harry would have inherited it. This would also be very ironic and a strange twist that would augment the relationship that was forged between Harry and Voldmort when the Dark Lord attempted to kill him.

********************************

So, these are my thoughts (again I'm not claiming to have had any of them originally or independently) about book 6. If you haven't checked out Rowling's official website, I would highly recommend that you do so. I'll leave it for you here:

http://www.jkrowling.com

I'd love feedback on these thoughts!

3 comments:

firewater said...

You're not alone on this; I also think that Snape is not evil. I think he's a very good guy. I mean, how many chances did he have to kill Harry or attack Dumbledore, or anything else? Plenty of times, but he didn't. Not just because Harry's got that protective shield his mother left behind, and not because Snape doesn't want to. It's sure that Snape has resentment, maybe deep-seated hatred (maybe....) and Dumbledore was gonna die anyway, it's just so much more of a twist this way.

I do believe that Regulus is RAB. If anyone else hasn't noticed, Regulus was mentioned a lot. There was also this whole story on why Regulus was not on the family tree. He was also mentioned by Slughorn, this time also tied to Voldemort. And he had not wanted in anymore, and that is why he was "killed" or something like that.

I also believe that Dumbledore's death is necessary for Harry's character to grow even more as a wizard. He's been going to school with the thought that if Dumbledore was there, he'd be safe. Now that Dumbledore's not there anymore, what would he do? He'd grow up, take more responsibility, step-up, whatever you call it. There'd be more stress, more worries about his friends' safety; a path to a very emotionally complicated plot just opened up.

I think that's all I have to say about the 6th book.

The Poor Blogger said...

I enjoyed reading your thoughts on book 6, although I'm offended that you didn't solicit mine! What, is there some English club that doesn't allow armchair reviewers from the Social Studies Dept?

http://poor-blogger.blogspot.com/2005/07/book-review-harry-potter-and-half.html

Anonymous said...

I think there is a hora-what's it in Black's house that Harry inherited. Remember how one of the death eaters was all up in a tizzy to get the Black's house at the very beginning of the book and they had the test with the house elf to see if Harry really owned it?

I've always liked Snape since book one... I think he's a teacher who just doesn't put up with any crap. I think he is just misunderstood.

Good writeup!