We're in the car after school and Vivian says, "Mommy, did you know that
George Washington had
slaves?"
Yes, I said. Many of the first presidents had slaves. She didn't say anything. I followed up with, "Does that bother you?" and she said it did.
"Well, you have to remember that at the time the George Washington was president, it was legal and even normal in our country to have slaves." She thought for a minute or so and sort of grunted, so I asked, "Does that bother you?"
"Yes," she said.
"Do you know why that bothers you?"
"No. I don't know," she said.
"Does it bother you because he was the President, and you think having slaves was bad or wrong, and it bothers you that because he was the president he shouldn't have been doing something that was wrong?" I asked.
"That's exactly why it bothers me," she said.
"Well, that's important that you're thinking about it. Sometimes even though something may be legal or even normal, there is a little voice inside you that will kind of warn you that something isn't right. It's important to pay attention when that voice tells you that," I said.
"But if it's wrong, how can it be legal?" she asked.
I said, "Well, sometimes it depends on the culture. For example, in some Islamic countries it is both legal and normal for a family to kill a woman if she has a relationship with a man she is not married to. Her family can kill her for that. It's called an honor killing. We think it's absolutely horrible and monstrous, ..."
"Um because that IS HORRIBLE. That is NOT OKAY!" she interrupted.
"...but culturally it is not for some people. It's important to know that just because YOU think something is morally wrong, sometimes other people will disagree with you and not understand," I finished explaining.
(Silence while they thought about this.)
"Sometimes even in our country, in our culture, things can be legal and even normal, and still be morally wrong. It's harder to recognize those instances when it seems familiar to you, so just pay attention and always question. It's important to listen to that voice inside you that points this stuff out," I said.
Owen said, "What is an Islamic country?"
I said, "You know how many people in the United States practice a religion called Christianity, right? Like we would be called Christians because we go to a church and believe in God and believe in Jesus Christ, right? So we are called Christians? When our country was originally founded, most of the people who came here were of the Christian faith. I am not sure about the statistics
today, but a lot of Americans are Christians, and so the United States is considered a Christian nation. Well, there are countries in the world where the majority of the people who live in those countries practice a religion called Islam, so those countries are called Islamic countries. And the people who practice Islam are called Muslims."
(Silence while they think about this.)
"Well, what does that mean? Do they believe in God?" Owen asked.
"Sort of. Like Christians, they believe that there is one God, but they don't call it God," I said.
"Well, what do they call her?" Owen asked.
(I want to stop here an interject that I think it is REALLY INTERESTING that Owen assigned a female identity to Allah. This is a kid who assigns gender identities to colors, and who's only experience with a singular divine presence is GOD, who he unquestioningly believes to be male.)
"Not her.
Allah is the word Muslims have for God," I said.
"Well, what do they believe?" he persisted.
"Um, honestly, I don't know a lot about Islam. I know that their word for God is Allah, and they have a Holy Book called the Koran, which like how we have a Holy Book in our faith called the Bible," I said.
And then we arrived where we were going, so we stopped having this conversation.
Can I just say that I was wholly unprepared to have a philosophical conversation in the car about morality and how that lines up with power? How do you even begin to explain the complexities, subtleties, and nuances of how we define right and wrong while in the car with an eight and ten year old? And how do you begin to think about and talk about how to navigate what to do when the person you perceive to have power (and who, therefore, as I infer from the comments the kids made) is making moral choices that conflict with your own personal understanding of right and wrong? And why do I feel like maybe I should have studied more in order to be prepared for this conversation? I feel like if I could have studied more, or been more informed about Islam and moral ambiguity and even historical facts about George Washington, that I could have offered more helpful illustrative examples, facts, and statistics to support my points.
#ParentingAintForSissies ya'll.