Here is the truth: real writing, good writing, writing that works because it makes connections (between ideas, between things, between readers)—the kind of writing that all English teachers dream of only to find themselves face to face with a reality that doesn’t come close to the dream—is wonderful, brilliant, dirty, messy, terrifying, and completely magical. The consequences of this kind of writing have meaning. I’m talking about meaning in multiple contexts far outside the scope of the teacher or the state assessor or George W’s NCLB. Real writing is a process. Real writing is a journey. Real writing can happen in a classroom, although more often than not, it doesn’t.
In the context of a classroom, we have to take a broad approach in our thinking when it comes to writing. I remember being a new teacher. It was painful. It was especially painful because I started teaching in an age when everything had to be bench marked and assessed and kids had to meet requirements based on standards that were more than a little vague in the reality of my classroom. I taught all kinds of kids, too, not just the kind of kids that show up in “gifted” classes more because they have a good work ethic than because they are particularly gifted in any way. Most of my kids, especially at the beginning, were so far removed from my limited life experience and so far behind what The State thought they should be able to do that I have to admit to feeling hopelessly lost when it came to teaching them to write.
It wasn’t really until I began my MA program that someone (Lil)—in the heat of an ugly conversation about the evils of the five paragraph essay—said to me, “I just don’t understand why, in the face of all the research, this five paragraph essay myth persists!” At the time, I didn’t have an answer because I was in favor of teaching this structured format, most likely out of fear. I’ll admit that I was “taught better” in my methods course in college even though I had not been taught better as a student (and be honest, the vast majority of teachers mirror their own instruction from the way they were taught). I even admit that I knew I didn’t write that way and that no one really did. I knew that the five paragraph essay was an educational invention which did not exist in the “real world,” but I was afraid to face my regular, run of the mill kids with, “Okay now boys and girls, today we are going to learn to THINK and be CREATIVE through writing!” That would be insanity. These were the children who had spent—probably the entirety of—their education regurgitating what the teacher said for multiple choice tests. How were they going to think and be creative? What does that have to do with education? THIS WAS SCHOOL! There is no thinking or creativity in school!! Deep down I knew learning to think and be creative was better for learning and dramatically improved writing, but I was terrified of wading through that deep water with 80 kids in tow (or having to justify any of this to someone like—gasp—an administrator or parent). I thought I would drown. Not to mention that really, public schools frown on inventive, creative teachers who buck the system and balk at scripted instruction. Teachers who think are dangerous. Students who think are not only dangerous, but also terrifying. We certainly can’t have thinking students growing up to be citizens of THIS country!
In this age of “objective assessment” English teachers find themselves in a difficult spot. Seriously, how can ANYONE objectively assess something that is at every stage inherently creative? Unfortunately, that reality doesn’t mesh well with the testing era. Enter the five-paragraph essay. The five-paragraph essay takes the messy creativity out of writing and writing assessment. Suddenly English teachers, like Math and Science teachers, can have something to use that essentially objectifies writing. Anyone can count sentences. If a student has five complete sentences in each of the five paragraphs of his or her essay then that essay is clearly superior to the student who only has three sentences per paragraph or is missing one or more of the required five paragraphs! This is obvious, right? I’ve even been sent to workshops that made a science out of grading the five-paragraph essay—we not only counted sentences, but “sophisticated” vocabulary and transition words! Surely sophisticated vocabulary and transition words coupled with five complete sentences in each of the five paragraphs that all are about the same subject comprise a well-written essay because we can all agree on that! If only it were so simple…
My short answer to Lil’s question is that teachers—even experienced ones who should know better—continue to use the five-paragraph essay because they are afraid of going through the messy stuff that is “writing” with students and they want to be able to objectively assess student writing in order to fit in with the testing era; not to mention, the vast majority of the teachers I know just really, fundamentally want to help their students be successful. It is so much easier to teach a kid to write five sentences in each paragraph for five paragraphs—and to reward them for this—then it is to teach them to really write well about something that matters for an appropriate audience. And if you get observed teaching kids to write five sentences per paragraph that will make so much more sense to the observer than having your students paste together a collage of magazine pictures which will later be used for creating a focus for an essay, or teaching organization, or heaven forbid sparking something like a poem which clearly has no place what so ever in the classroom prepping for the tenth grade writing test…
Sadly, schools and administrators actually encourage this—and parents/students want to know “exactly what they have to do” to get an A, or get a 6, or get out of the friggin’ tenth grade.
It is more work (requires more thought, more skill, more thinking, and more creativity) to develop a writer, which is what we Writing Project people mean when we say “teaching writing.” One can not develop a writer with the five-paragraph essay because one doesn’t have to be a writer, or any good at writing, or intelligent, or creative to fill in a form, which is essentially what the five-paragraph essay really is, you see? Forms are not messy at all and writing is just messy in so many ways; it’s messy because it is organic and fluid and infinite in possibility. How can a form encompass something like that? It would have to cease to be a form at all…in fact it would have to be a big wide blank space to be filled in and interpreted by another being capable of things like empathy and great thought and intelligence. This also means that by teaching writing (READ: developing a writer), teachers would have to develop readers capable of interpreting and expressing things like the nature of humanity. See? This is far too complicated for the five- paragraph essay!
As a teacher, I had to face the possibility of drowning with my students as we waded into the very deep waters of writing. I even had to cajole reluctant swimmers/writers into the murky depths as I myself struggled to swim/write. This required much more than I bargained for when I went into teaching and not just anyone can do it, which flies in the face of the public’s general understanding of teaching and education. In order to be a teacher who develops writers, I had to learn to be a writer and to share all the mess involved with my students. I suppose I could try to force all of this into a five-paragraph essay, but I don’t think I could do it…